Wednesday, March 7, 2018

There is poison in the mother but her milk is pure?

Are Taylor Marshall’s teachings part of the poison?

Like Cardinal Burke, Taylor Marshall is a promoter of the Association of Hebrew Catholics.

The Crucified Rabbi: Judaism & the Origins of Catholic 
Christianity by Taylor R. Marshall (2009) epub edition.

Dr. Marshall correctly states the fact that Talmudic Judaism and the faith 
of the Israelites in the Old Testament are not the same. (p. 33)

Here, Taylor Marshall explains that the Old Covenant was once salvific (p. 34) which is contrary to the Gospels, “For if justice be by the law, then Christ died in vain.” (Galatians 2, 21).  Isn’t Marshall’s position a form of Protestant Dispensationalism?

Dr. Marshall finds Talmudic statements, which condemn Gentiles, acceptable and in the next breathe says that as long as Gentiles are not cruel idolators [i.e. worshipers Jesus the Christ] they have a place in the world to come [where they will inherit hell]. (p. 227)

Just what type of milk is Taylor Marshall imbibing if he spouts-off the un-Catholic garbage above?

***** UPDATE 11 MARCH 2018 *****

Dr. Marshall has Opus (Ju)Dei connections at the least...


  1. He's also anti-SSPX. But who am I to judge?

  2. He can always go on EWTN Journey Home seems alot of anti-Catholic bashing by ¨converts¨ some who are lying their arses off if you know how to read body language.

    Speaking of EWTN one ¨Convert¨ said he will write a controversial book get it published by Ignatius press (he did) and going to the next step he will go on EWTN radio (he did)afterwards Journey Home, etc... even heard a Homily mention him when they serendipidity met each other on a pilgramage, how convenient. All his goals were achieved. Protestants are just spring boards for false conversos.

  3. Not all of us are false converts... I was confirmed at a “conservative” Novus Ordo parish in 2002 after nearly 10 years as an evangelical megachurch Protestant, and now assist at the TLM exclusively. I find men like Taylor Marshall repulsive (and feel the same about the army of Francis’ sycophants, mostly professional Catholics and former Protestants as well).

  4. He's opus die. Sure will be spirited to rome to join the burke-rosica-martin-francis pervert poison propaganda show.

    "Whatever the other problems at the College, and whatever falsehoods and exaggerations they’re hearing from Dr. Marshall, the actions of Msgr. Berg [fssp wolf] and Bishop Olson (and presumably others above them in the hierarchy) leave no doubt that they are trying to crush the old Mass, and disperse a group of people who are living the traditional faith."

  5. I watched this video and found it gross.